Ernesto Tiburcio

Research

Working papers

The Local Reaction to Unauthorized Mexican Migration to the US (with Kara Ross Camarena) [Reviewing]

We study the political and socioeconomic impacts of unauthorized Mexican migration to the United States. Our shift-share identification strategy combines variation in migration inflows and migrant networks using novel administrative data to capture unauthorized migration. With rich county-level data, we document conservative electoral, legislative, and policy responses. Recent unauthorized migration increases the vote share of Republican candidates and induces more support for conservative legislation. It decreases total public expenditure, prompting reallocation away from education toward support for law and order. Three mechanisms partially explain these effects: job losses in “migrant-intensive” sectors; White flight and residential sorting; and higher out-group bias.

Awards: Robert H. Durr and co-winner of the Best Paper in Political Behavior (MPSA)

Press coverage: How the surge in migration to the U.S. might affect 2024 (The Washington Post), Immigration Backlash (Marginal Revolution), Why Biden Needs an Immigration Deal (The New York Times), The two sides of immigration backlash (The Science of Politics)

Political Polarization and Counter-attitudinal Information Consumption and Internalization (Horacio Larreguy) [Revise and Resubmit, The Economic Journal]

Political polarization can have detrimental effects on democratic governance by undermining electoral accountability due to biases in how voters consume and process information. A growing literature, mostly from high-income countries, has identified promising interventions for reducing negative feelings towards out-partisans, and for increasing ideologically opposed information internalization by prompting citizens to be aware of biases stemming from emotions or partisanship. To assess whether these types of interventions can contribute to counterattitudinal information consumption and internalization, we evaluate the effectiveness of different depolarization treatments combined with a bias alert within a survey of nearly 2,500 respondents from a nationally representative panel in the heavily polarized context of Mexico. Videos designed to foster empathy and emphasize shared identities reduce partisan polarization by improving attitudes toward those from opposing parties. However, these depolarizing treatments do not increase the consumption and internalization of ideologically opposed information. A nudge encouraging individuals to adopt an open mindset before engaging with ideologically opposed information, in contrast, does lead to greater information internalization. These findings provide insights into the potential and shortcomings of scalable interventions that can help citizens process politically relevant information, regardless of their partisan affiliations.

Taking One for the Team: Shocks at Destination and Household’s Supply of Migrants (with Gustavo Fajardo, Emilio Gutiérrez, and Horacio Larreguy) [Reviewing]

We study how unemployment shocks in the US affect Mexican households’ migration decisions. We emphasize households at origin (as opposed to individuals) as the migration decision-making units. We show that negative changes in US labor market conditions, which diffuse through household members at destination to those at origin, generate a stronger reaction from more skilled Mexican households that have members abroad than less skilled households. We argue that the relative magnitudes of income and substitution effects drive this differential response across households with varying skill levels. These results also inform the literature on selection patterns in international migration, which suggests a new channel through which negative shocks in the host economy negatively affect the skill composition of subsequent migrants.

Political Polarization in the Global South (Horacio Larreguy) [Revise and Resubmit, Nature Human Behavior]

In the last two decades, low and middle-income countries (LMICs), especially Latin America and Asia, have seen a rise in ideological and affective polarization, along with democratic backsliding. Yet, research on the drivers of such polarization’s rise and persistence remains limited. We identify three general drivers of polarization systematically present in LMICs. First, echo chambers foster and reinforce false beliefs about opposing groups. Second, while diverse media could counter polarization, the dominance of biased traditional, digital, and social media has deepened it. Third, divisive political elites using hostile rhetoric and incivility exacerbate polarization by amplifying social and political divides. We highlight opportunities to further our understanding of the empirical relevance of these mechanisms in LMICs, as well as interventions informed by these mechanisms to counter polarization

Work in progress

The effect of immigration on the electoral behavior of migrants (with Vicky Fouka and Marco Tabellini) [Draft available upon request]

Politically mismatched (with Rachel Funk Fordham)

The effect of unauthorized Mexican migration on crime (with Reem Zaiour)

Remittances and deportations in Honduras (with Carlos Schmidt-Padilla and Giancarlo Miguel Oseguera Álvarez)

Magazuela, myth of reality? (with Rachel Funk Fordham, Jake Grumbach, and Dorothy Kronick)

Violence and education as drivers of emigration in Mexico (with Horacio Larreguy) [Draft coming soon]

Resting papers

Aid for Capacity and Infrastructure: Evidence from Bangladeshi Upazilas (with Horacio Larreguy)

We estimate the impact of the foreign aid program UGDP on electoral outcomes and civic attitudes in Bangladeshi Upazilas (sub-districts). We exploit the selection rules by implementing a regression discontinuity design, comparing otherwise identical sub-districts during the program’s first years. Participating in UGDP has an imprecise null effect on voting behavior in parliamentary elections and a significant and negative effect on civic attitudes, suggesting capture by the dominant party.

Policy reports

Larreguy, Horacio and Tiburcio, Ernesto. 2024. “Polarization: US Lessons for Latin America”. UPPER Policy Brief Series. DC Political Economy Center.

Niño-Zarazúa, Miguel; Horigoshi, Ana; Santillán Hernández, Alma, and Tiburcio, Ernesto. 2022. “The Rise of Social Protection in the Global South: The Role of Foreign Aid”. EBA Report 2022:08. The Expert Group for Aid Studies (EBA), Sweden.

Academic publications (pre-doctoral)

Filipski, Mateusz. J.; Rosenbach, Gracie; Tiburcio, Ernesto; Dorosh, Paul; & Hoddinott, John. 2021. “Refugees who mean business: Economic activities in and around the Rohingya settlements in Bangladesh”Journal of Refugee Studies 34(1), pp.1202-1242.

Hoddinott, John F.; Dorosh, Paul A.; Filipski, Mateusz J.; Rosenbach, Gracie; and Tiburcio, Ernesto. 2020. “Food transfers, electronic food vouchers and child nutritional status among Rohingya children living in Bangladesh”. PloS ONE15(4): e0230457.